Monday, June 16, 2014

What is a librarian?

Hi there!

So ... librarians, right? What a weird bunch of people librarians are, amirite!? What is UP with librarians?

(Mind you, I'm including myself in this hypothetical stand-up-comedy-worded vocational introspection about librarians)

I'll admit that I don't really get librarians. Are all professions as conflicted as we are?

I am speaking of course, about the dreaded "librarian stereotype".

"Oh don't you even start, Craig!", I can hear you saying. "Quite frankly, we're sick of talking about it", you say. "We're sick to death of hearing about how we all have the cat's-eye grandma spectacles, and how our hair is always in a bun, and how we all read a lot of books all the time, and how all we do is SHHH people. We are sick to death of it! Librarians are not like that! We are innovators, and progressive! We challenge the norm! We are on the front lines of the culture wars and we are radical movers & shakers! We are tattooed, pierced, and we are rock stars! We are changing the conventional paradigm every day!!".

I mean, that's what I think, anyway. I pretty much have the official rant memorized by now. Every time someone tells me that I don't look like a librarian, or when they make the predictable jokes about shhh-ing people, or when they nod at me knowingly and say: "Dewey Decimal System!" while pointing twin fingers at me handgun-style and making that clicky noise with their mouth. I can occupy at least an hour talking about how librarians aren't like they used to be. We're different now. The stereotype is wrong, mister! These are not your grandmama's librarians here!

We get really worked up about this shit, don't we?

But then I go to the ALA store at my local library conference, and what do I see? Cats, coffee, and cozy blankets. I do a simple search on librarian t-shirts, and they are all clever puns based on the stereotypical librarian archetype. How many librarian t-shirts do you own? Yes, I have the "Shhh Happens" one, the "League of Extraordinary Librarians", the "Don't make me use my librarian voice" shirt, and many more. I'm familiar with the online comedic stylings of Ambaum & Barnes, and I own a complete set of the NJ Librarians pinup-style trading cards. It seems to me like librarians just eat this shit up, but how dare you try to pigeonhole us into some kind of tired old stereotype. Even when we characterize ourselves as "rock star librarians" or "leak" photos of ourselves on the latest Think Tank "networking session" at the local watering hole; isn't that just an ironic wink and a nod to the idea of librarians as corny conservative fuddy-duddies? Isn't the idea of a "Radical Militant Librarian" just part of the joke? Isn't it playing up to the anti-stereotype? Why else would I dye my own hair purple if not to elevate "trying too hard" to an art form?

Then again, are we miscreant library types still the minority?

I mean 40 or 50 punk rebel maverick atypical librarians stuffed into a tequila bar at 2 in the morning during a conference sounds like a lot, but at a venue of 25,000 librarians, is that really even a dent? Are the grey-haired, tote-bag carrying librarians in respectable sweaters the norm, and the stereotypes are absolutely 100% true? Maybe it's just a matter of degree?

I like to think of myself as an atypical librarian, but I still do wear a sensible shirt and a tie. I have purple hair, but I'm not covered in piercings in tattoos. Is it all just a bell curve? For every purple-haired librarian, is there a middle aged woman in a modest cardigan with comfortable shoes, cat's-eye spectacles, a collection of crochet patterns and six cats waiting for her at home thinking: "Well I'm certainly not the librarian stereotype! I mean, my hair would look terrible in a bun!"?

And when we get right down to it, do we really want to change the librarian stereotype, or just leave that stereotype right where it is and continue do defy it in our own little personal ways?

No comments:

Post a Comment